
Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick & his alleged lover Chief of Staff Christine Beatty
Kilpatrick, family spend day in Florida as calls for ouster grow
January 24, 2008
By JOE SWICKARD, SUZETTE HACKNEY, JIM SCHAEFER and ZACHARY GORCHOW
FREE PRESS STAFF
The heads of Detroit’s 17 municipal unions may decide today that Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick should be asked to step down or face recall, as revelations that he and his chief of staff lied under oath at a police whistle-blower trial rocked City Hall.
Also today, a lawyer who represented the officers who sued acknowledged to the Free Press that there’s a confidentiality agreement containing undisclosed details of the $8.4-million case settlement, which was reached in October.
City lawyers had previously told the Free Press no such agreement existed.
On Wednesday the Free Press reported that their text messages show Kilpatrick and his chief of staff, Christine Beatty, lied at the whistle-blower trial when they testified last summer they did not have a sexual relationship.
On Thursday, Beatty was not in Detroit, according to her lawyer.
Kilpatrick and his family were in Tallahassee, Fla., trying to escape the public eye, but his office said they would return to Detroit Thursday evening.
As Kilpatrick was shown in photographs kissing his wife, Carlita, in Florida, stunned City Council members said Thursday they were preparing for the possibility that Detroit’s youngest elected mayor might not complete his second term.
Council President Ken Cockrel Jr., who would become mayor if Kilpatrick left office, raised the possibility of resignation although he did not call for the mayor to step down.
Cockrel said the contradictions between text messages obtained by the Free Press and the mayor’s testimony at the trial “seriously, seriously damages his credibility.”
“I’m not prepared to make that call at this point, but certainly if I was him and I was in his shoes, looking at the situation, I’d have to give serious consideration to whether or not I could save the city some further aggravation by making that move,” he said.
This morning, the eyes of the city will be on Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy, who has called a press conference to discuss whether she will launch a criminal investigation into Kilpatrick’s and Beatty’s trial testimony. Legal experts say that the previously secret text messages may furnish evidence to support perjury or obstruction of justice charges against the pair.
Alternatively, Worthy, who has declined comment so far, could ask for the appointment of a special prosecutor by state Attorney General Mike Cox.
John Riehl, president of the politically powerful AFSCME Local 207, which represents 900 municipal workers, said Thursday that the labor leaders will consider today whether they will ask Kilpatrick to leave office.
“Everybody hopes this is the end of his career. He’s done the city enough damage,” Riehl said. “If one of our people had done this kind of misconduct, we would be fired.”
Kilpatrick and the American Federation of State, County and Municipal
Employees have clashed in the past about attempts by the mayor to win concessions from city workers and privatize some city services. AFSCME represents about 5,000 of the city’s 15,000 workers.
The employee unions pack political muscle, and could employ strong networking and fund-raising abilities if they chose to launch a recall campaign.
Kilpatrick, his wife and their three children were photographed Thursday outside a $430,000 home they purchased in Tallahassee six months ago. Kilpatrick waved at photographers but did not give an interview.
He is a graduate of nearby Florida A&M University, where he was a star football player. Kilpatrick met his wife while both were students there.
After television stations aired video and still photos of the Kilpatricks in Florida, mayoral spokesman James Canning said the family would fly back to Detroit on tonight.
Beatty’s lawyer, Elliott Hall, said the next move is up to Worthy. “I need to see how she plans to proceed,” said Hall.
The lawyer representing three former cops who were paid $8.4 million to end lawsuits against Kilpatrick and the city said Thursday for the first time that the secret agreement sealed the deal.
The lawyer, Mike Stefani, said he could not discuss the confidential agreement. But the deal was not included in documents the city sent the Free Press in response to a freedom of information request seeking “any and all documents related to the settlement.”
The newspaper is now suing for those records. The city has responded in legal filings that it provided the newspaper with all the records.
Cox, who was in Washington on Thursday to testify before a Senate committee on an unrelated matter, told reporters that he had read accounts of the scandal but wasn’t planning any investigation.
“Usually the county prosecutors get first crack at that,” he said. “I’m really not interested in stepping on any jurisdictional toes.”
Contact JOE SWICKARD at 313-222-8769 or jswickard@freepress.com. Staff writers M.L. Elrick, Todd Spangler, Jennifer Dixon, John Smyntek, David Ashenfelter, Ben Schmitt and Kathleen Gray contributed to this report.